Sign in to view assessments and invite other educators
Sign in using your existing Kendall Hunt account. If you don’t have one, create an educator account.
Provide access to calculators or spreadsheets for every student.
Ask students what stories they may know about a person encountering a wish giver. This situation uses a magical fish, which has historical roots in many cultures including Chinese folklore (Ye Xian (YEE SHEE-ahn)), ancient English fables (The Fish and the Ring), and Haitian fairy tales (Tenzin the Fish).
In many traditions, wish givers are also tricksters that will try to corrupt a wish. Emphasize that being precise in language and explanation is helpful not only in the phrasing of a wish, but also in math class for communication.
Present the situation (either by asking students to read it quietly, or by performing a dramatic reading).
Ask students, “How much money will be in each purse after a week?” (After 7 days, Purse A will contain \$2,400 because it grows by \$200 each day for 7 days. Purse B will contain \$1.28. It doubles each day for 7 days, so it will have , or 128 cents (the 1 here represents the 1 cent in the purse when the purses are offered).) If no students mention using multiplication for repeated addition or an exponent for repeated multiplication, ask how they might use the number 7 to find the worth of each purse. Tell students to enter the amounts into the table in their Task Statement.
In addition to orienting students to the calculations, use this opportunity to point out that the convention here is that the days are numbered the same as the number of times additional money is added. For example, when the purses are initially offered, it is day 0. After the \$200 is added or the money is doubled once, it is day 1. Day 2 is when the money has been added twice.
While walking along a beach, you notice a fish trapped in a small pool. You release the fish into the ocean, but before it swims away, it turns to reward you for your good deed.
It tells you, "Thank you for freeing me from that tide pool! I was getting claustrophobic. You can choose one of these purses as a reward. You cannot add money to the purses, and once you take any money out, the magic is broken and no more money will be added, but you may keep what is inside."
| time passed | 0 days | 1 day | 2 days |
7 days |
14 days (2 weeks) |
21 days (3 weeks) |
30 days (1 month) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Purse A | \$1,000 | \$1,200 | \$1,400 | ||||
| Purse B | \$0.01 | \$0.02 | \$0.04 |
Complete the table for the amount of money in each purse for the given number of days after the fish offers the purses. Be prepared to explain your reasoning for each value.
Some students may confuse the units for the two purses. Remind them that Purse B contains pennies (and thus cents rather than dollars).
Due to prior experience with stories in which wishes or magical items are offered, students may be suspicious of the offers. Ask them to show their mathematical reasoning, rather than basing their choice of purses on their suspicions or other considerations, such as how to carry a purse containing over 2 million pennies.
Focus the discussion on how students found the amounts of money in the two purses after many days. Invite students who performed recursive calculations and those who wrote expressions or equations to share their reasoning. Record and display students' reasoning for all to see. Seeing the repeated reasoning will support students' generalization work later. For example, the amount in Purse A will be for day 1, then for day 2, for day 3, and so on. Connect this to writing expressions like and where represents the number of days since the fish offered the purses.
For Purse B, highlight the fact that after two days it contains cents, which is cents. After three days it contains cents, which is cents. This is a good opportunity to emphasize the meaning of exponential notation. Exponential notation is particularly useful for expressing the amount in Purse B on day 30, which is cents.
Conclude the activity by polling the class about which purse they would choose.
If no students use a spreadsheet, consider demonstrating how it might be helpful in performing calculations like these.
Here are graphs showing how the amount of money in the purses changes. Remember Purse A starts with \$1,000 and grows by \$200 each day. Purse B starts with \$0.01 and doubles each day. Point P has the coordinates , and point Q has the coordinates .
Due to the exponential nature of the problem, the scale for the vertical axis makes it difficult to accurately estimate vertical coordinates of points from the graph. Remind students that they know how the value of each purse is calculated, so they may use calculations similar to those in the previous activity to compute actual dollar values.
If color versions of the materials are not available, it may be difficult to determine which points correspond with which purse. Encourage students to imagine connecting the dots (perhaps using a ruler for Purse A) to distinguish the two sets of points.
To highlight the power of using graphs to illustrate what is happening in a situation, ask “You have used calculations and graphs to compare the offers. Did using graphs help? Did they add new insights to the offers?” (The graphs give a clear visual representation of how the amount of money in each purse grows. It is easier to tell when Purse B becomes a better option than Purse A, and how different the two values are at different points in time. They de-emphasize the actual numbers and, so, give a very clean comparison of the two situations.)
Use Stronger and Clearer Each Time to give students an opportunity to revise and refine their response to “Knowing what you know now, which purse would you choose? Why?” In this structured pairing strategy, students bring their first draft response into conversations with 2–3 different partners. They take turns being the speaker and the listener. As the speaker, students share their initial ideas and read their first draft. As the listener, students ask questions and give feedback that will help clarify and strengthen their partner's ideas and writing.
If time allows, display these prompts for feedback:
Close the partner conversations, and give students 3–5 minutes to revise their first draft. Encourage students to incorporate any good ideas and words that they got from their partners to make their next draft stronger and clearer.
As time allows, invite students to compare their first and final drafts. Select 2–3 students to share how their drafts changed and why they made the changes they did.